Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice was one of the most anticipated superhero films of its time, bringing two iconic heroes face-to-face in a dark, action-packed showdown. However, despite its star-studded cast and massive fanbase, the movie left many scratching their heads with some plot twists and character decisions that seemed confusing at best, and downright nonsensical at worst. Here are 19 things in Batman v Superman that just don’t make sense:
The Immediate Hatred Between Batman and Superman
Batman and Superman go from being unaware of each other’s existence to sworn enemies in no time. The lack of gradual tension or any real reason behind their animosity feels forced, making their eventual conflict less compelling.Lex Luthor’s Motivation
Lex’s grudge against Superman isn’t clearly explained. His erratic behavior and schemes seem convoluted, and it’s hard to understand why he’s so obsessed with taking down Superman in the first place.The “Martha” Scene
Batman’s change of heart after realizing Superman’s mother’s name is Martha is one of the film’s most criticized scenes. The entire premise of their fight is undercut by this odd, out-of-nowhere bonding moment over their mothers’ shared name.Batman’s Brutal Tactics
This Batman is far more ruthless than previous versions, killing and branding criminals. It’s jarring and inconsistent with the character’s traditional moral code, leaving fans wondering why this change was necessary.Lois Lane’s Role in the Plot
Lois seems to pop up wherever the action is, and her investigative role feels oddly shoehorned in. Her involvement in key scenes feels like plot convenience rather than organic storytelling.Why is Superman Blamed for the Capitol Bombing?
Superman is blamed for the Capitol bombing, even though he clearly didn’t plant the bomb. The logic of the public and government blaming him for being nearby when it happened feels weak.Lex Luthor’s Knowledge of the Heroes’ Identities
Lex somehow knows that Bruce Wayne is Batman and Clark Kent is Superman without any explanation. How he acquired this information is a mystery the film doesn’t bother to address.Batman’s Readiness to Kill Superman
Batman is so committed to killing Superman that he creates special weapons, including a Kryptonite spear. For a hero who rarely kills, this extreme approach seems out of character.The Flash’s Cryptic Warning
Flash appears in a dream sequence to warn Batman, but the message is confusing and unclear, leaving both Batman and the audience puzzled.The Appearance of Doomsday
Lex’s ability to create Doomsday from General Zod’s body and his own blood raises a lot of questions. The science and logic behind this are murky at best.Wonder Woman’s Limited Role
Wonder Woman is introduced but isn’t given much to do beyond a brief battle scene. Her role feels more like a teaser for future films than an essential part of the story.Superman’s Decision to Fight Batman
Superman could easily have explained himself to Batman, but instead, he barely tries to communicate, leading to a pointless fight that could have been avoided with a conversation.Lex’s Absurdly Complex Plan
Lex’s plan to pit Batman and Superman against each other is overly complicated and relies on too many coincidences, making it hard to believe that it would actually work.Batman’s Nightmares
Batman’s apocalyptic nightmares seem to foreshadow future events, but they don’t fit with the rest of the movie, leaving audiences confused about their relevance.Lois and the Kryptonite Spear
Lois throws away the Kryptonite spear, then realizes it’s needed, requiring Superman to save her again. Her actions feel more like filler than essential to the story.The Senate Hearing
The hearing where Superman is put on trial seems unnecessary and unrealistic, as the Senate could have simply met with him instead of staging a public spectacle.Clark Kent’s Journalistic Skills
Clark’s investigation into Batman feels half-hearted, as he makes little progress. For a seasoned reporter, his methods seem uncharacteristically ineffective.The Lack of Consequences for Batman’s Actions
Despite causing significant destruction, Batman faces no real consequences. His role as a vigilante feels too easily accepted by the authorities.Superman’s Sacrifice
Superman’s decision to sacrifice himself to kill Doomsday feels premature, especially given his near-invincibility. This scene, meant to be impactful, feels forced and unnecessary.
Batman v Superman had potential, but these puzzling plot points and character inconsistencies left audiences divided. While the film certainly has its thrilling moments, it’s hard to ignore these head-scratching elements that make it one of the more confusing superhero movies in recent years.
